i was thinking the same thing the other day

Both amazingly gorgeous! Exept Johnny has been hawt all his life. Judd was only hott wen he was younger. <3
xx

i agree all the way with megan's comment :D

what Megan said is totally true

yea man .. loveem both.
badasses :)

agreeed :D

i don't judd looks good, but johnny is hot

lol exactly what I think !

gahh what happened judd??
he was sooooo...
im crying for his lost beauty.

i think judd was cute when he was younger but not anymore and johnny is always cute <3

when judd was younger he looked like some realy hott guy that goes to my skool

Johnny Depp only looks good because he wears make up- ya whores.

Shut up Dave! Johnny looks just as good fresh out of bed as he does with the liner.
Judd Nelson was my first lusty crush

HOTIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

I LUV HIM <3<3

you can marry me judd. jonny depp already married. No. I am getting Married in Vegas this winter sometime in 2009. Moelay really pumps my nads.

which one, hotteeee? jonny depp is the hunk of the world. do you mean jonny depp?

Definitely

I think Judd was cool but he's really lost it.

judd you are so hot with a capitl h. Also your so hot in the breakfast culb.

how are you people so illiterate? There's barely any actual english going on in these comments.

my god im as sad as u lot judd all the way cant beat breakfast club

I just got told I look like Judd so I just checked what he used to look like in breakfast club I'm thinking maybe a little

Totally agree with Megan and similar comments. Judd was so hot in The Breakfast Club, but now.....well, he's the same age as my mom. Kinda says it all......

Judd Nelson is still fine as hell altho Johnny Depp is better lol

judd is so f***ing hot

OMG I LOVE JUDD NELSON HE IS SO HAWT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

i think dave is an idiot coming on here to tell us that we are whores because of who we like thats messed up johnny is the hottest ofd them all!!!

The Breakfast club is my all time favourite film. Judd was so hot in it, even though he's eight years older than my parents :P

i agree with megan with judd and johnny depp.... its sooo tru

Haha, this is great. But they're both equally ah-dorable :) <3

Judd Nelson is the sexiest

Judd Nelson is an alien! A sexy alien. Anyone notice how in the breakfast club he was supposed to be slower then the average bear? couldn't read that well etc. ? Well pay close attention and you will see he is very smart. Somehow he gets everyone to talk about there problems break out of there shell and more then likely prevented a suicide and a school shooting. Imagine that a fuck up save all the other people who everyone else wants to be in school. Also he and the janitor were quite close weren't they? Watch the end and Judd's facial expressions through the movie you'll see. Who gives a crap about there looks! It's the person inside the skin that matters and even so Judd takes the lead by far regardless of his aging and I'm 18! <3333 Judd!

Judd Nelson in the Breakfast club was such a great actor. I feel really sorry for his life in the breakfast club though because his dad put out his cigar on his arm and that looked really painful. he's really cute though!%Pr

johnny depp as jack sparrow was inspired by keith richards not judd nelson

Judd Nelson was uber hot back in the good ol' days of 'The Breakfast Club', but he's just [sadly] gone down hill in the looks department. Omg Johnny Depp is my all time hero, I love him, yeah he's gorgeous, but I appreciate him on another level to most people =)
And I agree with 'backyard caveman' Captain Jack Sparrow was inspired by Keith Richards and not Judd. I can see the fun idea you guys are all going on though with Judd and the shirt on his head, but it's just a random detail that someone picked up on. Which I must say is very well spotted!
btw any Johnny Depp fan's going to see 'Public Enemies' and 'Alice In Wonderland'?

depp shmepp JUdd is da hottest!!
omg i love john bender - i lurve bad boys!
judd all the way, swoon...

NOT IN THE SLIGHTEST! I THINK LONG HAIR AND BEADS AND I RED HANDKERCHIEF ARE PRETTY COMMON WHEN A PIRATE COMES TO MIND. PLUS ITS NOT LIKE IT WAS JOHNNY DEPPS DEPARTMENT TO DRESS HIMSELF. ITS CALLED A COINCIDENCE!

How can you compare them? They're different people and don't deserve to come under such scrutiny!!

Johnny is still SEXY and Judd was. I wish Judd looked like he did in the breakfast club he was the hottest guy i have ever seen

i LOVE judd in thee breakfast club:) "im being honest, asshole, id expect you..to know the difference" :)) soo hot in that movie :D but noo, johnny depp has ALWAYS been hot, and prolly always will, anyone els seen crybaby? hot damn!!!

WOW they are both really hot cept Judd only had the looks when he was younger.. And i LOVE johnny depp.. I thought it was so cool that he had a band cuz he is such an amazing singer...

Johnny Depp was soooo sexy in Secret Window! I love that movie. I love all the movies he is in because i get to look at his HOTTNESS, cant wait to see him in Alice in Wonderland

doesn't matter, you're so right - these are the dumbest people I've ever read.

ahhhh judd why did u have to loose ur cuteness waaaaaaa

yall guys? what r yall tALKING about? judd nelson is soooo HOT as john bender...i agree his looks don't improve with age, but he had his hey day right? give 'em a break! he's too old for ne of yous anyways. jonny depp? one word...ahhhhhh!!!! no amount, and i repeat NO amount of stage makeup can hide that beautiful face. too bad he's getting married...(again)..wonder how long that'll last? ") TOTALLY seeing Alice in Wonderland...but not for alice...for the Mad Hatter :)

i agree with what larissa said it's not up to johnny what he wears in a moive thats another persons job all together, i think judd is hot in the old days and johnny depp just makes my mouth water.

Actually Nelson doesn't look that bad nowadays. He does have put on a noticeable amount of weight, unlike Depp who's managed to stay rather thin, that's why he doesn't look that "good" when compared to Depp.